Roofing System Comparison Center
Compare every roofing system side by side to find the best fit for your home, budget, and long-term goals.
CHS Recommendation
For approximately 80–90% of homeowners, we recommend Architectural Asphalt Shingles because they provide the best balance of appearance, durability, warranty coverage, and long-term value. If your priorities are luxury appearance, maximum lifespan, or a specialty application, the comparison below will help you find the right fit.
Roofing Systems
Roofing System Comparison Table
Lifespan
Investment
Maintenance
Architectural Asphalt
Curb Appeal
Best For
3 of 5 Stars
Barns, Garages & Lower Metal Cost
5 of 5 Stars
Long-Term Homeowners
5 of 5 Stars
Estate & Luxury Homes
5 of 5 Stars
Long-Term Homeowners
Which Roofing System Is Right for Me?
If your priority is…
Best overall value
Luxury curb appeal
Lowest upfront investment
Longest lifespan
Slate appearance without slate cost
Natural rustic beauty
We recommend…
Architectural Asphalt
Designer Asphalt
Screw Down Metal
Standing Seam Metal
Synthetic Slate
Cedar Shake
FAQ’s
Low
30-50 Years
$$
Designer Asphalt
Low
35-50+ Years
$$$
Screw Down Metal
Moderate
25-40 Years
$$
Standing Seam Metal
Very Low
40-70+ Years
$$$$
Synthetic Slate
Very Low
40-50+ Years
$$$$$
Cedar Shake
Moderate
30-40+ Years
$$$$$
Most Homes
4 of 5 Stars
Luxury Homes
5 of 5 Stars
Still not sure?
Every home is different. Our team can help you select the roofing system that best fits your home, budget, and long-term goals.